Gulag Voices, Surviving the Gulag

The first two parts of the review of Anne Applebaum’s collection of writings by survivors of the Soviet slave complex were about daily life and women in the Gulag, which Applebaum writes is an acronym for the Soviet term “Main Camp Administration.” (Wikipedia says it is “Chief Administration of Corrective Labor Camps and Colonies.”) The people who wrote the memoirs were remarkable because they were literate and they survived. A large number of the estimated 25 million people who were sentenced to the concentration camps, labor camps, exile villages, criminal and political camps, and prisons did not survive. One writer observed only a few people in the slave camps would survive the first few months of imprisonment. There was mention of an unfunny joke that the first few years were the hardest. This part of the review is about how people used cleverness and religious faith to survive.

Dimitry S. Likhachev was an intellectual who was imprisoned after he was accused of counter-revolutionary activities. He and fellow literature club members saluted one another in ancient Greek, which was interpreted to mean he was an enemy of the state. He was arrested after an acquaintance visited him and asked whether his library had anything anti-Soviet after looking at a copy of Henry Ford’s The International Jew, describes Jews as “vicious capitalists and Bolsheviks.” He describes his initial imprisonment and some of the people in detail. One person in his cell had been the head of the Petrograd Boy Scouts. He mentions that a favorite game of the “warders” was to sweep a rat back and forth with brooms as it attempted escape until the rat died of exhaustion. He writes about the irony that he was arrested for meeting once weekly for intellectual discussions to be thrown in with people who had similar discussions continually while in prison. Likhachev was released after four years and became “…Russia’s best-known literary historian, critic, and scholar.” Continue reading

The Financial Crisis–Part I

There are those who advocate there weren’t enough regulations (read Barney Frank) to prevent the financial meltdown in 2008.   My contention is that the crisis began with numerous government regulations that encouraged home ownership for people who couldn’t afford homes. The regulators decided encouraging wasn’t a strong enough approach and began demanding that lenders make loans to people who couldn’t afford to repay them.  Greedy speculators noticed opportunities for profits by creating packages of  “subprime” (read “risky”) loans and selling them to other speculators.  The real estate bubble grew because of the artificial increase in demand. The collapse probably began when the first home couldn’t sell for the original purchase price.

The march to the crisis began when the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) was signed by President Carter in 1977.  That Act was the beginning of numerous actions by the government to encourage, or force, home loan agencies to make loans to borrowers in low income neighborhoods.  The intent was to open up the American Dream of home ownership to people who couldn’t previously convince their bankers they could repay the loans.  The Act was reinforced during the Clinton era by imposing penalties on loan agencies that didn’t meet requirements for loans in inner cities.  The CATO Institute warned in 1993 that the changes would be costly to the economy, and the warning was studiously ignored.

The push to make home ownership available to everyone continued into 2000.  The Government Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were directed to devote a significant percentage of their lending to support “affordable housing.” Fannie Mae announced in 2001 it had a goal to finance $500 billion in CRA loans by 2010.  The Federal Reserve joined the party by lowering interest rates, which encouraged new borrowers to initiate loans and others to refinance their loans and use the proceeds to buy new luxury items.

There have been charges that racism is involved in deciding who is given home loans.  A Princeton study confirms the validity of that charge.  African-Americans were more likely to be offered subprime loans compared to whites who had similar financial backgrounds.

Piggy Bank

Straight dope.com explains that ancient Saxons called the clay used to make household items, including jars used for storing money, “pygg,” which was pronounced “pig.” By the 18th Century it became common for the “pygg jars” to be cast in the form of a pig. The bank part of the term is not as simple as it seems. Bank originally meant “bench,” and money lenders worked at benches.

Records of Past Climate Change

The Supreme Court in 2007 declared that carbon dioxide and other “heat-trapping gases to be pollutants that endanger public health and welfare.” That ruling set the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in motion to establish regulations to control the gases. A New York Times article quoted the EPA as saying the science supporting the endangerment finding “compelling and overwhelming.” They proposed a law under the Clean Air Act to regulate “heat-trapping gases” (which includes methane, nitrous oxide, and hydroflurocarbons in addition to carbon dioxide). It is odd that the EPA has a paper that presents a solid argument that much of the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is the result of natural conditions separate from the activities of man. The paper first observes that the climate of the earth has changed throughout history preceding and following the arrival of man. Various scientific studies show that temperatures and carbon dioxide levels have been higher than present levels for about two-thirds of the last 400 million years. The causes of climate change are listed as:

  • Changes in the Earth’s orbit and tilt affect the amount of sunlight received on the surface of the planet
  • Changes in the intensity of the sun is an obvious cause of changes in temperature, and the NASA believes reduced solar activity was the cause of the “Little Ice Age” from the 1400s to 1700s
  • Volcanic aerosols block sunlight; the Tambora Volcano in Indonesia in 1815 lowered global temperatures by as much as five degrees Fahrenheit and caused 1816 to be “the year without a summer in New England 1816
  • Volcanic eruptions release carbon dioxide

I find the most interesting part of the paper to be a discussion under the bullet titled “Changes in greenhouse gas concentrations.” “The heating or cooling of the Earth’s surface can cause changes in greenhouse gas concentrations. For example, when global temperatures become warmer, carbon dioxide is released from the oceans. When changes in the Earth’s orbit trigger a warm (or interglacial) period, increasing concentrations may amplify the warming by enhancing the greenhouse effect. When temperatures become cooler, CO2 enters the ocean and contributes to additional cooling. During at least the last 650,000 years…during warm interglacial periods CO2 levels have been high and during cool glacial periods, CO2 levels have been low.” (Emphasis added) It is thus quite clear that those who blame changes in temperature on changes in carbon dioxide concentrations have ignored that the reverse is true.

I often read that Arctic sea ice coverage is continuing to shrink. I frequently look at the National Snow and Ice Data Center graphs of Arctic sea ice extent, and it is true that current coverage is less than the 1979-2000 average. However, the 2011 data is virtually tracking the 2007 levels (The amounts in April 2011 were higher than April 2007, but June 2011 levels are slightly lower than June 2007). How is it possible for no ice loss since 2007 translate to “continuing to shrink?” Current news reports are once again talking about severe and hot weather are being caused by global warming. The EPA paper describing the causes of past climate change would say that man has little influence on what may or may not happen.

Gulag Voices, Women in the Gulag

The first posting about the Annals of Communism edited by Anne Applebaum gave a summary of the memoirs that gave a view into daily life in the camps called the Gulag, which was an acronym for the Soviet term, “Main Camp Administration.” This posting is about women in the camps. Most of the memoirs have descriptions that are difficult to read, but I consider these memoirs to be the most difficult. Women were gang raped and/or had to use sex to survive. There is a very brief mention that it wasn’t just women who were victimized. It is described that sexual depravity was rampant, and that raping men was common. My interpretation is that the brutally inhumane conditions and treatment of the people resulted in destruction of their health, but also destroyed the humanity of many if not most of the prisoners. The memoirs of Elena Glinka and Hava Volovich are particularly disturbing.

Elena Glinka was a young engineer when she was arrested in 1950 and imprisoned for six years. She talked little about her experiences. There is a description of how women on a prison transport ship were raped, killed, and thrown overboard. Elena’s third-person memoir, the “Kolyma Tram,” describes how the prisoners gave the guards alcohol until they were in a drunken stupor after the word spread that women had arrived in the camp. (No explanation is given why they had access to so much alcohol.) The prisoners threw rags on the ground for makeshift bedding, lined up, and began to rape the women. One prisoner was the “Kolyma Tram driver.” He would shout, “Mount Up!” to signal it was the next man’s turn until the driver shouted “Show’s over!” Women who died were dragged to a pile of bodies while survivors were doused with water. The lines then formed again. Elena was spared the treatment of the other women. She was young and pretty, and the camp boss chose her for himself. She “…thanked God that she’d become the property of just one. Continue reading

Gone to Pot

This expression is used to describe anything or anyone who has declined with the passage of time. The term originated in the Middle Ages when table scraps were tossed in a big pot to make stew. Main courses from a big meal were thus demoted to leftovers, and gone to pot means going downhill.